Business customer disputes broadband… | Communications Ombudsman
close
arrow_back_ios
close
arrow_back_ios
close
arrow_back_ios
close
arrow_back_ios
close
arrow_back_ios
close
Raise dispute
Business

Business customer disputes broadband termination fee after Cloud Voice cancellation

1830 CO JM Case Study Contract Issues Website thumbnail

A business customer came to Communications Ombudsman after being told they could face an early termination charge when trying to cancel a broadband service that had been taken out to support their Cloud Voice service.

The dispute

The customer had received information from their communications provider informing them about the analogue switch-off and the need to move to a digital service.

As their landline number was important to the business, they arranged to move to a Cloud Voice service, and a broadband connection was also taken out to support the new service.

The Cloud Voice service was later cancelled after the customer said their landline had not successfully moved to the new digital service. As the broadband connection had been taken out specifically to support Cloud Voice, the customer also asked for the broadband service to be cancelled.

However, they were unhappy that cancelling the broadband would result in an early termination charge, despite no longer needing the service for its intended purpose.

The customer brought the unresolved dispute to Communications Ombudsman. 

Outcome

We reviewed the evidence provided by both sides and considered how the broadband and Cloud Voice services were connected.

The provider said the broadband was a separate contract and had been working as expected, so the early termination charge had been applied correctly.
We looked at how the services had been sold. The evidence showed that the broadband was taken out as part of the move to Cloud Voice, and that the customer had made clear it was needed to support the new phone service.

We found that the two services had been sold together for a single purpose. Once Cloud Voice failed and was cancelled, that purpose no longer existed. We did not consider it fair for the customer to stay tied to the broadband contract, or to pay to leave it, when the reason for taking it out had fallen away through no fault of their own.

We also found that the provider should have recognised the link between the services when the customer first asked to cancel. If it had closed the broadband at the same time as Cloud Voice, the customer would not have kept paying for a service they no longer needed and would not have had to bring the matter to us.

To put things right, we required the provider to cancel the broadband service without an early termination charge and to credit £111.34 for the broadband rental charged after Cloud Voice ended. We also required it to apply a £50 goodwill credit and send a written apology for the inconvenience caused.

Communications Ombudsman comment

Business customers can rely heavily on their communications services as part of their day-to-day operations, and issues can become more complicated where several services are linked.

In this case, the broadband service had been taken out to support the customer’s Cloud Voice service. Our role was to consider the individual circumstances of the dispute and the evidence available to determine an appropriate outcome.

Our independent and impartial dispute resolution process can result in a range of remedies depending on the circumstances of a case, including account credits, contract cancellations, financial awards and apologies.

If you run a small business and have an unresolved dispute with your communications provider, find out whether your business can use Communications Ombudsman.

You can also find out more about our dispute resolution process.


More case studies

Ready to raise your dispute with us?